Mon. Sep 15th, 2025

A Nine-Goal Thriller: Italy Edges Israel 5-4 in World Cup Qualifier After Defensive Horror Show

Debrecen, Hungary – In a match that defied tactical analysis and provided enough drama for an entire qualifying campaign, the Italian national football team, the Azzurri, secured a chaotic 5-4 victory over Israel. This World Cup qualifier, played out on neutral ground in Hungary, was less a display of footballing prowess and more a bewildering exhibition of both brilliant attacking flair and defensive fragility that left fans and pundits alike gasping for breath.

Italian and Israeli players in action during a thrilling football match
Action from the high-scoring World Cup qualifier between Italy and Israel in Debrecen.

The Unraveling of the Azzurri Defense

Under the guidance of coach Gennaro Gattuso, Italy arrived in Debrecen aiming to solidify their World Cup aspirations. However, what transpired was far from a routine affair. From the onset, the Azzurri appeared unsettled, their defensive lines resembling a colabrodo – a sieve – as the Italian press would later describe it. Israel, a team often underestimated, played with commendable courage, exploiting Italy`s tactical imbalances, particularly a persistent vulnerability on the left flank.

The early minutes saw the Israeli side, playing with black armbands in a solemn acknowledgment of recent tragedies in their homeland, capitalize on Italy`s disarray. It wasn`t long before the scoreboard reflected their efforts. A cross from Biton led to an unfortunate own goal by Italian midfielder Locatelli, putting Israel ahead. This was merely a preview of the defensive headaches to come.

Italy managed to respond before halftime. After some concerted pressure, Moise Kean found the net, leveling the score and offering a momentary sense of relief. Yet, the underlying issues remained, with Italy`s defense frequently scrambling and goalkeeper Donnarumma called into action more often than Gattuso would have preferred.

Second Half Frenzy: Goals Galore and Defensive Gaffes

The second half began with renewed Italian intent, but the defensive sloppiness persisted. Just when it seemed Italy was finding its rhythm, Israel struck again. Dor Peretz capitalized on yet another lapse, restoring Israel`s lead and sending a clear message: this was not going to be an easy ride.

What followed was an extraordinary sequence of events that highlighted both Italy`s offensive might and its alarming defensive frailties. In a whirlwind of action:

  • Kean quickly notched his second goal, restoring parity with a clinical finish.
  • Moments later, Matteo Politano put Italy in front for the first time, making it 3-2.
  • Gattuso made tactical changes, bringing on fresh legs like Frattesi and Orsolini, attempting to staunch the bleeding.
  • Substitute Giacomo Raspadori extended Italy`s lead to 4-2, seemingly putting the game out of reach.

However, the match was far from over. In a truly bewildering two-minute spell between the 87th and 89th minutes, Italy conceded two more goals. A calamitous own goal from Bastoni was followed swiftly by another strike from Dor Peretz, leveling the score at 4-4. The stadium, sparse as it was, buzzed with disbelief. It was a sequence that would have given heart attacks to statisticians and tactical purists alike.

Tonali`s Late Heroics and The Road Ahead

With the clock ticking into injury time and Italy seemingly staring at a disastrous draw, midfielder Sandro Tonali emerged as the unlikely hero. Receiving the ball in a crowded area, his shot-cross found its way into the net, securing a dramatic 5-4 victory for the Azzurri. The final whistle, after eight minutes of nerve-wracking added time, brought a collective sigh of relief for Italian supporters worldwide.

“This team has a huge heart because even after the 4-4, we pushed until the very end. Gattuso has six points from his first two matches and has found the right attacking duo in Kean-Retegui. Not bad as a calling card for a new coach.”

While the result keeps Italy firmly in contention for the top spot in their World Cup qualifying group, level on points with Israel (who have played one more match), the manner of the victory raises serious questions. Gattuso`s initial two games have seen his side score an impressive 10 goals, but concede four, including two self-inflicted wounds against Israel. This high-wire act of attacking brilliance masking defensive woes is a recipe for excitement, but perhaps not for sustained success.

As the Azzurri look ahead to crucial fixtures, including a match against a “tender” Moldova side for Norway, the lessons from Debrecen will be paramount. Italy`s “gran cuore” and offensive firepower are undeniable assets, yet a serious overhaul of their defensive organization is clearly needed if they are to navigate the complexities of World Cup qualification without inducing further cardiac arrest among their loyal following. The journey to the World Cup promises to be anything but dull for this unpredictable Italian squad.

By Gareth Pendleton

Gareth Pendleton is a dedicated combat sports journalist based in Manchester. With over a decade covering everything from boxing to Muay Thai, he's become a trusted voice in the British fighting scene.

Related Post